G-Drive and privacy: where do YOU draw the line

Posted by Ryan Jerz 12/05/2007. Permalink | Shortlink | Tweet it!

I wrote yesterday in The Hurl about Google’s to-be-released-sometime G-Drive. What enticed me to write about it was the article I came across in Popular Mechanics that spoke of the privacy concerns pf uploading all of your files to a third-party storage facility, especially one that is known to comb through that data in an effort to push ads on the people using their products. It’s an interesting question, but not one that we haven’t been asked before.

It has become pretty common for you, me, and just about everyone we know to use a great service that also happens to be offered by Google—Google Mail. When it launched in 2004, many of the very same things were brought up. There were articles calling Google evil and there is even a site lambasting Google over their mail service. The privacy concerns were largely ignored, it seems, by most of us, and according to “Tim O’Reilly, correctly. We now use Gmail as our mail client of choice.

Why would the use of an online hard drive be any different? For the vast majority of users, there simply isn’t any reason to be afraid of what Google might accidentally come across with a routine scan of files in order to properly place contextual ads.

So what I’m asking is that you explain your position. Where do you draw the line? What are your concerns? Does the introduction of a superior online storage product (there is nothing that indicates Google won’t hit this out of the park) outweigh the possibility that your files will be scanned?

I recognize that in order to preserve freedom there must be advocates at the far end of the spectrum. That’s why I’m asking what I’m asking. I’d venture to guess a lot of the people who are worried about Google’s products invading privacy haven’t really thought about how far they’re willing to be pushed before they break. I plan on using G-Drive extensively if/when it’s finally released. I’m not concerned about the possibility that they may know what I wrote in a file or how much money I have in the bank. I fit the clichéd argument that I have nothing to hide. But I am thinking about how far I’ll go. I don’t know the answer yet, but I can say that I haven’t been pushed far enough yet.

Ryan JerzRyan Jerz is an all-around good guy who shoots photos and video, builds websites, and works in athletics at the University of Nevada, Reno. He received a Masters Degree in 2007 from the University of Nevada, Reno's Reynolds School of Journalism.

Comments

Josh wrote:

From a technical perspective, Google doesn’t have enough resources to care about the content of files any more than finding ads that are relevant. There aren’t actual humans sitting besides the scenes trying to match up your docs to advertisers, just bits of code that run 24×7.

However, it can be scary to think that these same programs could start to track common keywords to your profile until they have a good knowledge of who you are and what you do. I’m just not convinced that there is anything bad about learning your users in this way.

I will use the service, but I fear they will give you an amount of disk space that is too small – like 5 Gigs. If they only give an amount this small, the user has to decide or prioritize which files are most important. And since the files that fall below this line are still important, the user will still have to find other backup methods. This will make an effective backup strategy more complicated than it should.

I fully expect this service to be more than just online storage. This has been done and isn’t too complicated. Google has been working on this system way too long to just roll out another product in this crowded category. I’m hoping it has some revolutionary features that moves the whole backup paradigm forward – like Time Machine on the Mac.

Anyway, my 2 cents.

Dec 6, 02:53 PM


Wolfy wrote:

I’m with Josh, except the part about using that service. I have a web host. What do I need more web storage for? Google docs is good, but falls short in terms of usability, though it’s handy.

Seems to me that storage isn’t going to be much of an issue. If anything I’d see a 500gig thumb drive with all your profiles on it that you can use to make any machine YOUR machine.

And I could could count the times I’ve clicked on an add in gmail on Aron Ralston’s right hand…

-M

Dec 8, 04:34 AM


Commenting is closed for this article.